LGBTQ PEOPLE OF FAITH

Giving them visibility and a place at the table

Background:

In 2004, I had my first book launch with around 350 people in attendance. For many of them, it was their first time at a gay venue, making it an especially exciting evening. Yet, something was missing.

Although my publisher had sent out invitations, there were no LGBTQ community leaders present, no gay press to cover the event, and no mention of my autobiography in the weeks that followed.

Had I overestimated the significance of what was happening? Here I was, a former high-profile Pentecostal preacher, coming out as gay and sharing my story—the first Australian conversion “therapy” survivor story to be told.

To put it in today’s context, imagine one of Brian Houston’s Hillsong pastors or one of his children publicly coming out. Such an event would undoubtedly attract significant media attention.

THE PROBLEM:

I found out later that the lack of interest, even avoidance, was a strong anti-religion feeling that existed in the community. I was unaware, not only of its existence but also of its prevalence.

Since that time, I’ve come to understand that this anti-religion attitude has deep historical roots. At the first Pride march in New York and the inaugural Mardi Gras in Sydney, LGBTQ individuals of faith had to fight for inclusion in the parades. The resistance they faced was both intense and hostile. Imagine that—being rejected by your religious community, only to encounter further hostility from those you thought were your new family, your tribe.

I soon realized that I would have to contend with these reactions for a long time, and even today, they occasionally resurface.

The media has long established the narrative that the church is anti-gay. Stories of religious harm, such as conversion “therapy” or the religious discrimination bill, are often highlighted. While these stories are true and have been used to raise awareness and advocate for protection and equality, they do not represent the whole story.

Ironically, both the LGBTQ community and religious conservatives have been preaching a similar message: You can’t be gay and a Christian, Muslim, Jew, etc. They’ve framed these identities as mutually exclusive, leaving many feeling trapped between two worlds.

OUTCOMES OF THE ANTI-GAY/ENEMY NARRATIVE

  1. What impact does this have on LGBTQ people whose faith is important to them? It can be like living constantly in a war zone and ducking bullets from both sides. Do they feel safe coming out about their faith in the LGBTQ community, or does their faith become another unhealthy closet of fear and a false sense of shame?
  2. It also affects families where religion is very important. They are being fed a narrative that the LGBTQ community is against everything they stand for. I’ve often wondered how much this contributed to the 38% of Australians who voted NO on the marriage equality postal survey.
  3. What about the young person in a religious home who is coming to terms with being LGBTQ? Is this contributing to the belief that one day they will have to choose one or the other?

THE SOLUTION: (Creating visibility and a place at the table for LGBTQ people of faith)

No one can change the narrative but us. We can start by promoting positive stories about LGBTQ people of faith, highlighting their experiences and contributions.

By increasing the visibility of LGBTQ individuals who embrace both their identity and their faith, we ensure they are recognised as valued members of our community, with a rightful place at the table.

This approach directly challenges the conservative anti-gay narrative.

THE BENEFITS OF VISIBLITY FOR LGBTQ PEOPLE OF FAITH:

  1. Affirmative Action: When young LGBTQ individuals in religious homes feel ready to come out or live authentically, they will know there’s a place for them within our community. If things don’t go smoothly, they’ll have a safe refuge to turn to.
  2. Support in Times of Struggle: LGBTQ people grappling with conflicts between their faith, sexuality, or gender identity will understand they are not alone. They’ll see that others have walked this path and found acceptance.
  3. Thriving in Affirmative Spaces: LGBTQ people of faith will thrive in their lives and relationships when surrounded by an affirming and non-adversarial environment.
  4. Deconstructing the Adversarial Approach: Over time, by fostering visibility and acceptance, we can deconstruct the adversarial mindset, allowing us to focus our energy on more constructive and positive endeavours.

Comments and feedback are welcome.

Sincerely

Anthony Venn-Brown OAM (he/him)

Founder and CEO of Ambassadors & Bridge Builders International (ABBI)

Please add your thoughts and comments below. Thanks